Money, Banking and Financial Markets

Commentary

Commentary

 
 
Posts tagged Margin call
Resolution Regimes for Central Clearing Parties

Clean water and electric power are essential for modern life. In the same way, the financial infrastructure is the foundation for our economic system. Most of us take all three of these, water, electricity and finance, for granted, assuming they will operate through thick and thin.

As engineers know well, a system’s resilience depends critically on the design of its infrastructure. Recently, we discussed the chaos created by the October 1987 stock market crash, noting the problems associated with the mechanisms for trading and clearing of derivatives. Here, we take off where that discussion left off and elaborate on the challenge of designing a safe derivatives trading system―safe, that is, in the sense that it does not contribute to systemic risk.

Today’s infrastructure is significantly different from that of 1987. In the aftermath of the 2007-09 financial crisis, authorities in the advanced economies committed to overhaul over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives markets. The goal is to replace bilateral OTC trading with a central clearing party (CCP) that is the buyer to every seller and the seller to every buyer....

Read More
Steve Cecchetti and Kim SchoenholtzCCP, Central clearing party, Clearinghouse, Over-the-counter, OTC, Derivatives, Exchange-traded derivatives, Over-the-counter derivatives, Margin, Margin call, Initial margin, Resolution, Stress test, Reverse stress test, Systemic risk, Financial infrastructure, Financial market utility, FMU, Bailout, Capital, Notional value, Swaps, Volatility
Black Monday: 30 Years After

On Monday, October 19, 1987, the Dow Jones Industrial Average plunged 22.6 percent, nearly twice the next largest drop—the 12.8 percent Great Crash on October 28, 1929, that heralded the Great Depression.

What stands out is not the scale of the decline—it is far smaller than the 90 percent peak-to-trough drop of the early 1930s—but its extraordinary speed. A range of financial market and institutional dislocations accompanied this rapid plunge, threatening not just stocks and related instruments (domestically and globally), but also the U.S. supply of credit and the payments system. As a result, Black Monday has been labeled “the first contemporary global financial crisis.” And, a new book—A First-Class Catastrophe—narrates the tense human drama that it created for market and government officials. A movie seems sure to follow.

Our reading of history suggests that it was only with a great dose of serendipity that we escaped catastrophe in 1987. Knowing that fortune usually favors the well prepared, the near-collapse on Black Monday prompted market participants, regulators, the lender of last resort, and legislators to fortify the financial system.

In this post, we review key aspects of the 1987 crash and discuss subsequent steps taken to improve the resilience of the financial system. We also highlight a key lingering vulnerability: we still have no mechanism for managing the insolvency of critical payment, clearing and settlement (PCS) institutions....

Read More
Steve Cecchetti and Kim SchoenholtzStock market, Financial instability, Crash, Volatility, Clearing, Settlement, Clearing and settlement systems, Payments system, Leverage, Counterparty risk, Financial market utility, FMU, First-mover advantage, Margin, Margin call, Dodd-Frank Act, CHOICE Act, Derivatives, Clearinghouse, Liquidity, Long position, Short position, CAPE ratio, Futures, Options, Collateral, Central bank independence, Lender of last resort
Can Margin Requirements Improve Financial Resilience?

Eight years after the financial crisis began, the regulatory reforms it spawned continue apace. Over the past year, regulators introduced total loss absorbing capacity (TLAC) and the liquidity coverage ratio (LCR) to make banks more resilient. And, with an eye toward strengthening market function, authorities continue to push for central clearing of derivatives (CCPs).

Overlapping with these goals—and extending to nonbanks—is the recent move to establish standards for margin requirements in securities transactions: that is, the maximum amount that someone can borrow when using a given security as collateral...

Read More
Steve Cecchetti and Kim SchoenholtzFinancial regulation, Fire sale, Margin, Haircuts, Repo, Securities lending, Central clearing party, Financial market utility, Tri-party repo, Collateral, Margin call, Margin requirements, Financial stability